My night in the ED

I have been a pediatrician in the ED, a hospital executive, and a consultant on organizational development. And every time I have to interact with the health care system as a patient or family member, I am embarrassed by the clinical, administrative, and organizational weaknesses of my own profession. Something is very wrong, and it’s not about money.

At 10 PM one night during a recent out-of-town stay, my 3-year-old slipped off the bed and cracked his head open on the corner of a nightstand. The laceration was a little less than a centimeter but showed subcutaneous tissue. So, at the suggestion of my son’s pediatrician, off we went to the ED of a prominent children’s hospital.

We arrived at about 10:30 PM and were immediately triaged. The actual wait began at about 11 PM, although I am sure their statistics say that we were seen within minutes after arrival.

The waiting room contained about 10 to 12 families. Because most looked less than urgent, and because a wave of 4 to 5 families was called in after half an hour, I decided not to declare myself as a pediatrician and gave the organization a chance to do its best.

Although the triage nurse was pleasant enough, the staff overall was aloof and spent more time interacting with among themselves than with the patients. My son played with my phone, and the time passed easily for him; not so for my wife and me.

Finally at about 12:30 AM, a nurse fetched us from the waiting room and showed us into an exam room. In what we think was an attempt to enhance patient satisfaction, she pointed out the TV controls and the nurse call bell, all the time sounding like she was reading from a script. She re-examined my son, questioned us again, and left with a mention of returning to put some topical anesthetic on the wound.

She had not returned by 30 minutes later, and I pushed the red call bell. After 10 minutes, I picked up the phone, spoke to an operator, and asked that someone come to our room. Another 10 minutes, and the nurse arrived.

Now, at 1:30 AM, I revealed my professional status and made it clear that we were not pleased. I didn’t demand immediate care; instead, I asked for a plan of care with the estimated time that each step would take. She looked bewildered by my request and left.

Minutes later a resident arrived, bumbling a little, and explained they were busy with a wound next door. After some fumbling around, she irrigated the wound with demonstrable inexperience; having once been a neophyte myself, I let it go.

But that was the thing that flipped the switch for my son. It was now close to 2 AM, and he just couldn’t hold it together anymore. The attending came in to close the wound with glue; the closure was less than perfect. We discussed removing the adhesive and repeating the closure; the discussion was couched in “if you want to, I will” language, which I have used myself.

I hid my fury at the whole thing—as a pediatrician I was embarrassed at the relative ineptitude of my fellow professionals; as a manager and former hospital executive, I was incredulous at the lack of discipline in their systems; and as a parent, I was a little overwhelmed. So I chose to spare my son another round of intervention and accepted both the level of care provided and the fact that my son may have a slightly bigger scar than if we gotten care 3 hours earlier.

Perhaps if my son had been sicker—DKA, blast crisis, head trauma—we would have gotten better attention. Notice I did not say better care. The problem here is the focus—or lack of focus—on the human side of the experience. It is beyond belief that our trip to the ED required a 4-hour wait for a 15-minute intervention, but more important is the lack of personal attention or connection associated with our experience. And that is a matter of choice, not cost.

Comment on this item in the space below.

Please log in to enter comments.
  • It's incredibly sad that you feel this is appropriate behaviour in an emergency department. Surely you, as a pediatrician who has worked in emergency, can understand that the staff in such a place is busy dealing with emergencies.

    Surely you, as a parent, are capable of looking at a subcentimentric scalp laceration, washing it out, placing a bandaid, and kissing it better.

    Surely you, as a professional, understand that you are stepping all over "professional courtesy" and doing a massive disservice to your profession by behaving like a spoilt entitled brat. I am embarassed that any physician would behave like that.

    redrabbit, 3 years ago | Flag
  • Very interesting blog entry.  Lots of messages here to consider.  One that jumps out at me is you last statement, that "It is a matter of choice, not cost."  You're right, it is a matter of choice, according to Viktor Frankl.  We need to remember that bad behavior is not justifed by bad behavior.  There is no justification for using bullying techniques for getting one's way.  It doesn't matter what the situation is or reasons are.  Like it or not, even when we are patients or patient family members, throwing a fit and losing control speaks to our basic lack of compassion and understanding in the first place.  A physician's role should include leading people, not pushing them.  You might have been a patient's father, but you were, still are, and always will be, a physician.  As a parting shot, one could make a case that depending on the level of one's irritation and anger expressed in a similar situaton, that such behavior is obstructive to patient care.

    tkob, 3 years ago | Flag
  • There are so many issues that you bring up in this blog that are at the root of what is "wrong" with our emergency health care system - and they are not what you are talking about. It is the sense of entitlement, inpatience, arrogance, and absolute mis-understanding of the word "emergency" that is so prevalent.   It should not matter who you are, how much money you have, what you have donated, or whether you are throwing a major tantrum that should affect the order you are being seen in the ED.  Your son CLEARLY did not have an emergency and unfortunately you should have CLEARLY understood this as a pediatrician.  Even my young children understand what "emergency" means.  These are events that you would call 911 for.  If your son is happily sitting in an ED waiting room for hours upon hours, playing with your phone, etc. I would be hard pressed to find any elementary aged child that would consider this an emergency. I am not a phycisican, but I find so much fault in your blog that I worry about other phycisians that could be so inept that they couldn't even figure out the status of "emergency" in their own home and then set out to blame those that finally took care of you (and your son).  Shame on you!

    andy, 3 years ago | Flag
  • The problem is the hidden lawyer in every exam room. I face this everyday in my busy practice. A crisis in one exam room makes everyone else wait. There is no way for me to speed up the process by skipping over the government-required unnecessary steps. Everything must by filled out according the letter of the law. There's no way I can just walk into a room and fix the problem at hand and then walk out. I'm being judged on my paperwork, graded on my patient interaction skills, and threatened by potential lawsuits at every turn.

    Every ambulance chasing lawyer,and self-righteous citizen activist needs to be involuntarily extracted from the medical system. Let doctors practice medicine!

    It's an imperfect science -- accept it. We don't need more legislation in order to reduce medical errors. We're far beyond the inflection point of diminishing returns. Additional monies should be spent in other arenas of economic life like schools, infrastructure, and scientific research, as well as parks, recreation areas, and school sports programs. I sincerely hope that for every person at the end of their life, they can look back with joy at the great society provided to them through the wise distribution of limited resources.

    jagsmith7, 3 years ago | Flag
  • I'm "just a nurse" but last time my three year old got a small simple laceration I cleaned it and glue it at home instead of taking up valuable time in an Emergency Department then get frustrated at the staff because my needs weren't being met fast enough. Did you also lie on the floor and kick your legs when you revealed your professional status? I expect the staff was very courteous and professional you just couldn't see beyond your own nose to notice. Give me a break. We don’t’ like making people wait, but sometimes heart attacks and trauma happens.  Either start taking care of your own or learn to be respectful and patient.

    NurseNate, 3 years ago | Flag

Inappropriate Flag

Flagging notifies the Modern Medicine Community webmaster of inappropriate content. Please flag any messages that violate the Terms of Service. Please include a short explanation why you're flagging this message. Thank you!

If you believe this content violates the Terms of Service, please write a short description why. Thank you.

Inappropriate Comment Flag

Flagging notifies the Modern Medicine Community webmaster of inappropriate content. Please flag any messages that violate the Terms of Service. Please include a short explanation why you're flagging this message. Thank you!

Email Friends

Your First Name (optional)

Email Addresses (comma separated)

Import friends

Message to Friends (optional)

Are you human?

Or, you can forward this blog with your own email application.

Terms of Service

 
 
 
 
Click here